GLOBAL   NEWS   PAKISTAN

GLOBAL   NEWS   PAKISTAN

Trump, Xi and Putin Leave Shenzhen Summit Short on Results

Trump, Xi and Putin Leave Shenzhen Summit Short on Results

Shenzhen (GNP): US President Donald Trump met Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen on Thursday, but the first three-way summit of its kind produced little beyond a symbolic statement, according to analysts.

The meeting took place on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) gathering. Trump arrived hoping to regain standing abroad after his Republican Party lost control of Congress in this month’s midterm elections.

He also remains in a tense stalemate with Iran over a war that polls show is unpopular and that has pulled down his approval ratings.

Against that backdrop, the three leaders agreed on a “peace declaration” reaffirming that nuclear war should never be fought. They announced no plans for the arms control talks Trump has long wanted.

They also showed no sign of progress on Iran, Ukraine or Taiwan, or on trade and artificial intelligence (AI) disputes. Instead, the leaders appeared willing to play down their differences.

That worked in favor of the other two participants. Xi strengthened his diplomatic image by hosting a major power gathering, while Putin presented Russia as an equal of the two most powerful leaders without making significant concessions.

Some analysts say the outcome could weaken Trump’s position as he enters the final phase of his presidency and strengthen two of Washington’s main rivals. Christopher Preble, a senior fellow at the Stimson Center in Washington, said Trump got the pageantry he loves but little substance.

The White House sees it differently. Spokeswoman Anna Kelly said Trump’s Asia events showed the respect world leaders have for the United States and that he will meet anyone who can advance its interests.

Trump himself gave the summit a rating of 12 on a scale of zero to 10. His definition of success has often put as much weight on spectacle as on agreements, and he suggested before the meeting that Xi’s welcome at the airport, with a full military ceremony, was already a win.

Comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Conference had worried Ukraine, which is in its fourth year of war with invading Russian forces. Yet the Shenzhen meeting lasted under 90 minutes, while Yalta ran for more than a week and ended in sweeping decisions.

European allies were still unhappy. They met in Berlin on Thursday to show support for Ukraine, and they objected to Trump calling Putin a “friend” while Europe sat out the talks. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz described the meeting as mainly a photo opportunity.

Criticism is also building at home. Senate Democratic leader Charles Schumer called the summit a historic embarrassment and said Trump secured no lasting commitments from China or Russia. His words matter because Democrats will gain more congressional power in January.

Also Read: Trump Fires Cyber Director After Week of Tech Outages

Not every expert dismissed the meeting. Daryl Kimball, executive director of the Arms Control Association, called it positive that the countries with the three largest nuclear arsenals backed the statement. The leaders also agreed to a nuclear risk reduction dialogue, though without a time frame.

Kimball added that the world needs far more than words. Trump later said a three-way nuclear arms deal is very hard to reach, partly because China has resisted such talks, since its arsenal is much smaller than those of the other two powers.

The next test could come in mid-December, when Trump hosts the Group of 20 summit at his Florida golf resort. Xi is expected to attend again, and Putin could appear too, although he has not been formally invited.

With two years left in office, analysts expect Trump to keep pursuing personal diplomacy. Josh Lipsky of the Atlantic Council said history will judge it by “what is the resolution in Iran, what is resolution in Ukraine, if any.”

+ posts

Managing Editor at Global News Pakistan (GNP), with a Bachelor's degree in International Relations from Riphah International University, graduated with a Gold Medal. Reach out at sabahtareengnp@gmail.com